1997 Action at the Supreme Court of the United States of America
THE ACTION - STOP EXECUTIONS!
From: Abolitionist Action Committee
Sheltering for a few days at the Center for Creative Non-Violence,
Founded by Mitch Snyder and located in Washington, DC
2:00am, January 18th, 1997
18 protesters, who were arrested at the United States Supreme court after
the largest action of anti-death penalty civil disobedience in recent US
history, spent 10 hours in jail Friday (January 17, 1997). 14 were released on bond, and all
were ordered to appear in Federal Court on Saturday morning to enter
their pleas.
The protesters came to Washington, D.C., from states across America:
California, Texas, Kansas, Michigan, and Pennsylvania were only a
handful of states represented by those who came to stage the act of civil
disobedience.
One protester even flew to Washington from Germany, and participated in
the action which resulted in his arrest. Other attendees at the anti-death
penalty rally came from France, with significant aid from friends in the
United Kingdom.
The "Stop Executions!" banner was unfurled at 10:02 am on the steps of
the Court; police began warning the protesters at 10:06 that they faced
arrest if they did not disperse, but the protesters stood their ground,
chanting and singing. Police began arresting the protesters one by one, but
the banner remained unfurled until the last demonstrator was arrested at
10:23 am.
The protesters represented a variety of organizations, including the Kansas
Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty, Murder Victims Families for
Reconciliation, the Friends Committee to Abolish the Death Penalty, the
Texas Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty, Catholic Worker, Equal
Justice USA, Pax Christi USA, Campaign to End the Death Penalty and
Virginians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty.
Supreme Court police said they could not remember any act of civil
disobedience at the Court surrounding the issue of the death penalty, and
added that Friday's action resulted in the largest mass arrests at the Court
in at least six years.
The feeling as this action commenced from the top of the steps, and the
sight from the sidewalk below could be described with many adjectives,
but the most common word heard was, "Wow!" (Or in the case of the
Supreme Court Police, "What happened!?!" ;-) )
THE COURT CASE - WASHINGTON, D.C. (July 03/1997)
Superior Court Judge Robert Morin convicted 7 of 15 anti-death penalty
demonstrators and ordered them each to pay $50 to a fund for crime
victims. The demonstrators had unfurled a 30-foot long banner which read
"STOP EXECUTIONS !" on the steps of the US Supreme Court on Jan. 17,
1997, the 20th anniversary of America's 1st execution, in which Gary
Gilmore was shot to death in the Utah State Penitentiary.
The 7 convicted defendants had each represented themselves in court
before the judge.
Judge Morin then added that he needed more time to sort out legal
arguments advanced by the remaining defendants, who claimed that a law
prohibiting demonstrations and assemblies on the Supreme Court grounds is
unconstitutional because it violates their 1st Amendment right to free
speech. The judge said he would rule on their cases on October 6.
Wearing buttons and t-shirts expressing their solid opposition to capital
punishment, the defendants crammed into a jury box for a 3-day trial that
gave them a forum to air their views on the death penalty and freedom of
speech and assembly.
Testimony during the trial indicated that the Supreme Court Public
Information Office and the Supreme Court Police both have no written
guidelines governing who may assemble on the Courts steps legally.
Testimony also showed that the demonstrators were arrested for refusing
to leave the steps after being warned and that they were not arrested for
unfurling the banner itself.
All of those convicted said that the real focus of the trial was the
nature of the US death penalty.
But Assistant US Attorney Theodore Marcus repeatedly maintained that the
trial was about an illegal demonstration, not capital punishment. He
said the restrictions at the Court are necessary to preserve decorum and
to shield the justices and their staffs from raucous political debates,
although the authorities conceded that the protesters did not threaten
anyone or cause any harm.
And at the Supreme Court Wednesday, a coalition of groups and a variety
of anti-death penalty speakers highlighted a boisterous rally
commemorating the 21st anniversary of the Gregg v Georgia court decision
which re-instated the death penalty in America.
The rally was highlighted by an emotional speech by DC Councilman Sam
Johnson, who urged DC residents to unite and work to keep the death
penalty out of the District. Texas Senator Kay Bailey Hutchison has said
she will sponsor legislation to bring the death penalty to Washington,
D.C., for anyone convicted of killing a police officer, or anyone
convicted of even attempting to kill a police officer.
The rally coincided with the 4th Annual Fast and Vigil for Abolition of
the Death penalty, sponsored by the Abolitionist Action Committee. Over
40 protesters staged the fast and vigil from June 29-July 2,
commemorating the Furman and Gregg Supreme Court decisions.
SUPREME COURT DEFENDANTS TO APPEAL CONVICTIONS
Yesterday (October 06/1997), seven of eighteen death penalty opponents arrested last
January 17th were convicted in D.C. Superior Court for holding a banner
on the plaza of the United States Supreme Court. The banner said,
"STOP EXECUTIONS!" They held the banner to mark the 20th
anniversary of renewed use of capital punishment in this country.
Present at court yesterday were defendants Abraham Bonowitz of
Los Angeles, Joseph Byrne of Washington, DC, Stephanie Gibson of
Baltimore and Kurt Rosenberg of Philadelphia. Three others were
excused from the hearing, and eleven more had been previously found
guilty.
"The Supreme Court, the one institution whose job it is to be the
final arbiter of human rights abuses and speech issues in this country,
should not be able to exempt itself being criticized for its stance on the
death penalty," said Abraham Bonowitz, one of the defendants and part of
the Abolitionist Action Committee, an ad-hoc group of individuals
concerned about the death penalty. "Our banner was our headline'."
In an 18-page opinion, Associate Judge Robert E. Morin, himself
a former defense attorney who had represented death row inmates, denied
the seven's request to dismiss the charges on the basis of free speech and
assembly. Instead, he found each guilty of violating a law which
prohibits assembling on Supreme Court grounds, but he "suspended the
imposition of sentence" after hearing pre-sentencing statements from each
defendant present. He also imposed a $50 fee to be paid by each
defendant into a fund for victims of violent crimes in the District of
Columbia.